Ricotta cheese: creamy, rich, and versatile. It’s a staple in Italian cuisine and a beloved ingredient in dishes like lasagna, cannoli, and cheesecake. But have you ever wondered which brand of ricotta cheese reigns supreme? Which one truly delivers the ultimate taste experience?
At our taste test, we set out to answer these questions. We carefully selected 9 nationally available brands and even included a homemade version from a local dairy to provide a benchmark for comparison. Our expert panel of tasters evaluated each brand based on taste, texture, and suitability for baking. The results? They might surprise you.
Key Takeaways:
- Find out which ricotta cheese brand came out on top in our ultimate taste test.
- Discover the criteria we used to evaluate the ricotta cheese brands.
- Learn about the difference between traditional and modern ricotta cheese.
- Explore the top-rated ricotta cheese brands and their individual strengths.
- Uncover the secrets behind the homemade ricotta from a local dairy, the clear winner of our taste test.
Traditional vs. Modern Ricotta Cheese
Ricotta cheese can be made in two different ways: traditional and modern. Traditional ricotta is crafted from the whey that remains after cheese production, typically parmesan. The process involves adding an acid and heating it until the remaining proteins coagulate. This unique production method gives traditional ricotta its distinct texture and flavor.
In contrast, modern ricotta is created using fresh whole or skimmed milk, to which acid is directly added. This results in a creamier and often fattier ricotta cheese. The modern approach prioritizes convenience and offers a smoother texture compared to its traditional counterpart.
In our comprehensive taste test, we included a variety of both traditional and modern ricotta cheese brands to explore the differences in flavor, texture, and suitability for various culinary applications.
To better understand the nuances of ricotta cheese production, let’s delve deeper into the characteristics and qualities of each type.
Traditional Ricotta Cheese
Traditional ricotta cheese is a product of age-old cheese-making traditions. It is crafted using the whey left behind after the production of other cheeses, typically parmesan. During the production process, an acid is added to the whey, causing the remaining proteins to coagulate. The resulting curds are then separated and drained, leaving behind the velvety and grainy ricotta cheese we know and love.
Traditional ricotta cheese offers a subtle, slightly sweet flavor with hints of the cheese it was made from. Its texture is crumbly and delicate, providing a pleasant contrast in both sweet and savory dishes. The distinct separation of curds and whey gives traditional ricotta a unique character that sets it apart from its modern counterpart.
Modern Ricotta Cheese
Modern ricotta cheese has embraced convenience and innovation in its production process. Fresh whole or skimmed milk is used as the main ingredient, eliminating the need for whey. An acid, such as vinegar or lemon juice, is added directly to the milk, causing it to curdle. The resulting curds are then strained to create modern ricotta cheese.
Modern ricotta cheese boasts a rich, creamier texture compared to the traditional variety. Its flavor is milder and less tangy, allowing it to adapt well to a range of dishes. The absence of whey in the manufacturing process contributes to its smoother and denser consistency.
“Traditional ricotta cheese, made from whey, carries the legacy of time-honored cheesemaking techniques. Modern ricotta, on the other hand, caters to the needs of the contemporary culinary landscape, prioritizing convenience and creaminess.”
The Brands in Our Taste Test
For our taste test, we selected 9 nationally available ricotta cheese brands: Whole Foods 365, Sorrento, Calabro, Trader Giotto’s, Polly-O (Made by Kraft), Organic Valley, Tofutti (Vegan), White Rose, and Shop Rite. These brands represent a range of options from traditional to modern ricotta cheese, as well as a vegan option. We also included a homemade ricotta from a local dairy as a comparison. Each brand was evaluated based on taste, texture, and suitability for baking.
Before diving into the detailed reviews and rankings, let’s take a closer look at the ricotta cheese brands that participated in our taste test:
- Whole Foods 365
- Sorrento
- Calabro
- Trader Giotto’s
- Polly-O (Made by Kraft)
- Organic Valley
- Tofutti (Vegan)
- White Rose
- Shop Rite
“Ricotta cheese, the creamy and versatile dairy product, has long been a staple in various cuisines. Our taste test aims to unlock the finest ricotta cheese brand available in the market. The ricotta cheese brands that made the cut in our evaluation include both traditional and modern variations, with a special vegan option. By examining factors like taste, texture, and baking suitability, our comprehensive review offers insightful recommendations for ricotta cheese enthusiasts.”
Criteria for Evaluation
In our taste test, we focused on three main criteria for evaluating the ricotta cheese brands: taste, texture, and suitability for baking.
Taste
The taste of ricotta cheese should be fresh and creamy, without any sourness or off flavors. A high-quality ricotta cheese will have a mild and pleasant taste that enriches the dishes it is used in.
Texture
The texture of ricotta cheese is an important factor in its evaluation. It should be slightly grainy, composed of soft and creamy curds. A desirable texture should not be chalky or rubbery, indicating a lower quality product.
Suitability for Baking
Baking is a popular application for ricotta cheese, so it is essential to evaluate its performance in this context. The ricotta cheese should maintain its texture during baking and not turn grainy or release excess moisture. A good ricotta cheese for baking will contribute to a creamy and delectable final product.
We thoroughly considered these criteria when assessing each brand in our taste test to determine which ricotta cheese stood out as the best in taste, texture, and suitability for baking.
| Criteria | Rating |
|---|---|
| Taste | 5 stars |
| Texture | 4.5 stars |
| Suitability for Baking | 4 stars |
Top Ricotta Cheese Brands
After conducting the taste test and evaluating the ricotta cheese brands based on our criteria, we found that the top five brands stood out from the rest. These brands showcased the best taste, texture, and suitability for baking. The homemade ricotta from a local dairy also emerged as a clear winner in terms of quality. Let’s take a closer look at the top five brands and their individual strengths.
-
Whole Foods 365: Creamy and Versatile
Whole Foods 365 ricotta cheese impressed us with its creamy texture and versatility. It had a smooth and fine grain, and the taste was fresh and mild. However, it is important to note that this brand is not suitable for baking, as it is stabilized with gums, which can cause graininess and excess moisture when cooked.
-
Sorrento: Affordable Creaminess
Sorrento ricotta cheese stood out for its creamy texture and affordable price. It had a slightly grainy texture, which added to its overall appeal. The taste was creamy and pleasant, although some tasters found it to be slightly sour. This brand performed well both on its own and in baked dishes.
-
Calabro: Smooth and Flavorful
Calabro ricotta cheese impressed us with its exceptionally smooth texture and rich flavor. It had a fine grain and a creamy mouthfeel that made it a delight to taste. This brand scored high marks in both plain taste tests and in baked dishes.
-
Trader Giotto’s: Creamy and Convenient
Trader Giotto’s ricotta cheese stood out for its creamy texture and convenient packaging. It had a smooth and creamy consistency that made it enjoyable to eat on its own. While it performed well in taste tests, it fell slightly behind in baking, as it did not hold up as well in terms of texture.
-
Polly-O: Classic and Reliable
Polly-O ricotta cheese, made by Kraft, showcased a classic flavor and reliable texture. It had a mild and neutral taste, with a texture that was loose and curdy enough to mix easily with seasonings for dishes like stuffed shells. This brand was a favorite among tasters and performed well in both plain taste tests and baking.
These top-rated ricotta cheese brands have consistently delivered the finest quality, earning them the highest ratings in our taste test. From creamy textures to rich flavors, they have truly set themselves apart from the competition. Whether you’re using ricotta cheese in savory dishes or delectable desserts, these award-winning brands are sure to elevate your culinary creations.
Whole Foods 365: Creamy and Versatile
When it comes to ricotta cheese, Whole Foods 365 has truly impressed us with its creamy texture and versatility. This brand offers a delightful eating experience with its smooth and fine grain that melts in your mouth. The taste is fresh and mild, making it perfect for savory dishes and desserts alike.
However, it is important to note that Whole Foods 365 ricotta cheese is not suitable for baking. This is because the cheese is stabilized with gums, which can cause graininess and excess moisture when cooked. So, while it may not be the top choice for your lasagnas or cheesecakes, it certainly shines in other applications.
In summary, Whole Foods 365 ricotta cheese is a must-try for its creamy texture and versatility. Enjoy it in pasta dishes, spreads, dips, or even desserts like cannoli. Just remember to explore other options for your baking needs.
Whole Foods 365 Ricotta Cheese Overview:
| Texture | Taste | Suitability for Baking |
|---|---|---|
| Creamy and smooth with a fine grain | Fresh and mild | Not suitable for baking |
“Whole Foods 365 ricotta cheese offers a creamy and smooth texture that lends itself beautifully to various dishes, from savory to sweet.”
Sorrento: Affordable Creaminess
Sorrento ricotta cheese is a standout in terms of both creamy texture and affordability. This brand offers a delightful balance of richness and affordability, making it a popular choice among ricotta cheese enthusiasts. The slightly grainy texture of Sorrento ricotta adds a satisfying bite to dishes, enhancing the overall eating experience.
The taste of Sorrento ricotta cheese is creamy and pleasant, with a hint of tanginess that adds complexity to its flavor profile. While some tasters may find it slightly sour, the overall creaminess of this brand shines through. Whether enjoyed on its own or used in baked dishes, Sorrento ricotta performs consistently well.
When it comes to price, Sorrento ricotta cheese offers an affordable option without compromising on quality. It allows budget-conscious consumers to enjoy the velvety smoothness and delicious taste of ricotta cheese without breaking the bank.
| Brand | Texture | Taste | Affordability |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sorrento | Slightly grainy | Creamy with a hint of tanginess | Affordable |
Overall, Sorrento ricotta cheese stands out as an excellent choice for those seeking a satisfyingly creamy texture, enjoyable taste, and affordability. It performs well in both simple taste tests and complex baked dishes, making it versatile for various culinary creations.
Stay tuned for the next section where we explore another top-rated ricotta cheese brand that offers a smooth and flavorful experience for epicurean enthusiasts.
Calabro: Smooth and Flavorful
Calabro ricotta cheese impressed us with its exceptionally smooth texture and rich flavor. It had a fine grain and a creamy mouthfeel that made it a delight to taste. This brand scored high marks in both plain taste tests and in baked dishes.
Trader Giotto’s: Creamy and Convenient
Trader Giotto’s ricotta cheese stood out in our taste test for its creamy texture and convenient packaging. This brand offered a smooth and creamy consistency that made it a delightful choice for enjoying on its own. The richness and creaminess of Trader Giotto’s ricotta cheese truly elevated its taste and mouthfeel.
In our evaluation, Trader Giotto’s ricotta cheese performed well in terms of flavor, with an enjoyable and mild taste. However, when it came to baking, it slightly fell behind in maintaining its texture. While it didn’t hold up as well as some other brands, its creamy and smooth consistency made it a great addition to various dishes.
Trader Giotto’s ricotta cheese is a convenient option for those looking for a creamy and flavorful addition to their recipes. The easy-to-use packaging makes it practical for everyday cooking and baking needs. Whether you’re incorporating it in pasta dishes, adding it to desserts, or enjoying it as a standalone treat, Trader Giotto’s ricotta cheese offers a smooth and indulgent experience.
Polly-O: Classic and Reliable
When it comes to classic and reliable ricotta cheese, Polly-O, made by Kraft, takes the spotlight. It delivers a mild and neutral taste that appeals to a wide range of palates. With its loose and curdy texture, Polly-O ricotta cheese is perfect for mixing with seasonings and incorporating into dishes like stuffed shells.
Our taste test panel had a clear favorite in Polly-O, as this brand consistently impressed with its performance in both plain taste tests and baking. Whether enjoyed on its own or used as a key ingredient in your favorite recipes, Polly-O ricotta cheese is a dependable choice that never disappoints.
| Brand | Taste | Texture | Suitability for Baking |
|---|---|---|---|
| Polly-O | Mild and neutral | Loose and curdy | Excellent |
Homemade Ricotta: The Clear Winner
The homemade ricotta from a local dairy emerged as the clear winner in our taste test. Made with traditional methods and using fresh ingredients, this ricotta cheese had a light and fluffy texture that resembled the best artisan ricotta. It had a rich and creamy flavor that surpassed all the store-bought brands. If you have access to a dairy that makes fresh ricotta, it is undoubtedly the best choice for the ultimate ricotta cheese experience.
Conclusion
In conclusion, our taste test reveals that when it comes to choosing the best ricotta cheese brand, it is important to consider factors such as taste, texture, and suitability for baking. After evaluating 9 nationally available brands and a homemade ricotta from a local dairy, we have identified the top five brands that stood out in our test: Whole Foods 365, Sorrento, Calabro, Trader Giotto’s, and Polly-O (Made by Kraft).
Each brand showcased its own unique strengths, but the homemade ricotta from a local dairy emerged as the clear winner in terms of quality and flavor. Made with traditional methods and using fresh ingredients, this ricotta cheese had a light and fluffy texture that resembled the best artisan ricotta. Its rich and creamy flavor surpassed all the store-bought brands, making it the ultimate ricotta cheese experience.
Whether you’re using ricotta cheese for savory dishes or indulgent desserts, make sure to choose a brand that delivers on both taste and texture. The top five brands from our taste test offer a range of options to suit different preferences and culinary needs. So, explore and enjoy the world of ricotta cheese, and elevate your recipes with the best ricotta cheese brand for an unforgettable culinary experience.