Cherry Bitters – Easy Angostura Substitute Recipe

Looking for a way to add a unique twist to your cocktails? Want to elevate the flavors of your favorite drinks? And what if we told you that you can create a batch of cherry bitters that will last for years, right in your own home?

So, here’s the question: Why settle for store-bought bitters when you can make your own homemade cherry bitters as a substitute for Angostura bitters?

With this easy recipe, you can customize the flavorings and tailor the recipe to your own preferences. Whether you prefer a touch of cinnamon or a hint of chamomile, homemade cherry bitters provide a versatile and personalized ingredient for your cocktails.

So, let’s dive into the power of cherry bitters and discover how you can create your own batch at home!

The Power of Cherry Bitters

Cherry bitters offer a subtle yet delightful boost to cocktails, adding a hint of fruit while retaining the bitterness that is essential in recipes like the Manhattan. While cherry bitters are not as widely available as other types of bitters, making them at home allows you to customize the flavorings to your own taste. Whether you prefer a touch of cinnamon or a hint of chamomile, homemade cherry bitters can be tailored to suit your palate. They can be used in a variety of classic cocktails, such as the Old Fashioned and the Rob Roy, as well as in unique recipes created by mixologists.

The Recipe for Homemade Cherry Bitters

Creating your own batch of homemade cherry bitters is a simple and rewarding process. With just a few key ingredients, you can make a flavorful and aromatic bitters that will elevate your cocktails to new heights. Here is a step-by-step guide to making cherry bitters from scratch:

Ingredients:

  • 1 cup cherries, pitted and halved
  • 1 cup neutral grain spirit
  • 1 tablespoon dried bittering agents (such as gentian root, quassia chips, or wormwood)
  • 1 teaspoon whole spices (such as cinnamon, cloves, or star anise)
  • 1/2 cup rye whiskey

Instructions:

  1. In a clean glass jar, combine the cherries, bittering agents, and whole spices. Cover the jar and let it sit for one week in a cool, dark place.

  2. After one week, strain out the solids from the cherry mixture, using a fine-mesh sieve or cheesecloth. Discard the solids and transfer the liquid to a clean jar.

  3. Add the neutral grain spirit and rye whiskey to the liquid in the jar. Stir well to combine.

  4. Close the jar tightly and allow the mixture to steep for an additional two weeks in a cool, dark place.

  5. After two weeks, strain the mixture once again to remove any sediment or cloudiness. Transfer the resulting liquid to a bottle for storage.

  6. Your homemade cherry bitters are now ready to use! They can be stored at room temperature for up to one year.

To ensure the best flavor, be sure to use high-quality ingredients and follow the measurements closely. Feel free to experiment with different types of cherries or spices to create your own unique flavor profile. Your homemade cherry bitters will add a delightful cherry note and a balanced bitterness to your cocktails, enhancing their complexity and depth of flavor.

Tips and Variations for Homemade Cherry Bitters

Once you have familiarized yourself with the basic recipe for homemade cherry bitters, it’s time to get creative and explore different tips and variations to enhance the flavor profile of your bitters. Here are some suggestions to help you customize your homemade cherry bitters:

Tweak the Spice Blend

Experiment with the quantities of spices used in the recipe to achieve a taste that suits your palate. You can increase or decrease the amounts of individual spices, such as cinnamon, cloves, or cardamom, to create a unique flavor profile. Just remember to keep track of your modifications so you can recreate your favorite variations in the future.

Explore Flavor Combinations

Don’t be afraid to mix and match different flavors to create a more complex and interesting cherry bitters. Consider adding complementary ingredients like orange peel, ginger, or star anise to the mix. These additional flavors can enhance the overall taste profile and provide a delightful twist to your cocktails.

Experiment with Different Types of Alcohol

While the recipe calls for neutral grain spirit, you can also experiment with other types of alcohol, such as vodka or bourbon, to add a different character to your cherry bitters. Each type of alcohol will contribute its own unique flavor notes, so feel free to explore and find the combination that resonates with your taste buds.

Remember, the joy of making homemade cherry bitters lies in the freedom to tailor the recipe to your preferences and taste. By adjusting the spice blend, exploring new flavor combinations, and experimenting with different alcohols, you can create a wide range of unique cherry bitters variations that complement your favorite cocktails.

homemade cherry bitters tips

Where to Find Specialty Ingredients

When making homemade cherry bitters, you may need specific ingredients that are not commonly found in regular grocery stores. For instance, gentian root and quassia chips are essential components of the recipe. So, where can you find these specialty ingredients?

One option is to visit specialty herb stores. These stores often carry a wide range of herbs, spices, and botanicals, including the unique ingredients required for making cherry bitters. You can inquire with the store owner or staff about their selection and availability. They might also be able to suggest alternative options if a particular ingredient is out of stock.

Another convenient option is to shop online. Online retailers like Lhasa Karnak offer a variety of specialty ingredients for bitters-making. You can browse through their inventory, compare prices, and easily order the items you need from the comfort of your home. Just make sure to check the shipping policies and estimated delivery times to ensure your ingredients arrive in a timely manner.

It’s important to note that the recipe suggests using 151-proof neutral grain spirit. However, this high-proof alcohol may not be readily available in all areas. Don’t worry! You can easily substitute it with the highest-proof vodka you can find. The key is to use a strong alcohol that will extract the flavors from the cherries and other ingredients effectively.

By knowing where to find these specialty ingredients, you can ensure that you have everything you need to make your own cherry bitters. So, whether you decide to visit a local specialty herb store or explore online options, acquiring the necessary ingredients is the first step towards creating your personalized batch of homemade cherry bitters.

Image

Enjoying Your Homemade Cherry Bitters

Once you have made your homemade cherry bitters, it’s time to start enjoying them in your cocktails. Our homemade cherry bitters can be used as a substitute for Angostura bitters in various classic recipes, such as the Manhattan and the Brooklyn. Their unique cherry flavor adds a delightful twist to these iconic drinks, enhancing their complexity and depth.

But don’t stop there – get creative! Our cherry bitters can be incorporated into unique cocktails that showcase their distinct flavor profile. Try Milk & Honey’s Dutchess, a sophisticated concoction that pairs beautifully with the cherry notes of our bitters. Or indulge in Beloved’s The Henry, a refreshing and vibrant cocktail that will leave you craving for more.

Not in the mood for a complex cocktail? No problem. With just a few dashes of our homemade cherry bitters, even a simple soda water can be transformed into a refreshing and flavorful drink. The subtle bitterness and fruity undertones of our cherry bitters will elevate your plain soda water to new heights, making it a delightful treat for any occasion.

So go ahead and experiment! Discover new ways to use your homemade cherry bitters and let your mixology skills shine. With each sip, you’ll experience the unique flavors and aromas that only our homemade cherry bitters can provide. Get ready to impress your friends and elevate the taste of your favorite drinks with this versatile ingredient.